The question always remains – can a guy and girl be strictly friends? Throughout my years (which, by the way, do not at all make me wise or knowledgeable), I have come to a few conclusions. A girl and guy CAN be strictly friends only under a few circumstances:
- BOTH are in relationships with other parties
- The time frame of the friendship is temporary - not BFFAEAE so to speak
- There is something that one finds inherently unattractive in the other; one or both don't have to necessarily be ugly, just not appealing to the other
If one of these conditions is not met, the guy and girl will hook up. Or date. Or get married and have kids and divorced and continue the cycle. Or live happily ever after – to be charmingly optimistic. The worst option is that one will TRY to hook up with the other, and in turn “ruin” the friendship. The interesting question to me is: if that happens, and the two continue to be friends, is that friendship fake or forced? If one is interested and finds some sort of unrequited lust in the other, are they still “just friends?”
Take my friend “Fish” for example. We’ve been friends since literally the sixth grade – friends for 12+ years. That’s literally half of my lifetime! So you can understand why I thought we were literally “just friends” (that's a lot of "literally")… he’s like a lovable brother! Recently, Fish and I have been meeting up at Starbucks/any other café to get coffee or tea together. He always makes me laugh, I do a pretty good job of reciprocating, and we chat about life, plans, boys/girls, nothing at all… essentially just shoot the shit. It’s nice to have someone with whom to be “just friends,” especially of the opposite sex so you can ask him his viewpoint on certain issues and guilelessly assume that his opinion speaks for the entire male race. Obviously.
Now, refer to the rules listed above. Neither of us is in a relationship currently. We’ve been friends for a long time. I think Fish is super attractive, he dresses well (snowboarder, Sevens and R&R, tight sneaks and tight tees, fashionable stoner, urban prep… all in one. That’s a mouthful), and he is my type (except a little on the Napoleon side if ya know what I mean). I could just never view him in that respect! Ever. Eek! And he seemingly finds me attractive for whatever reason that may be. So, according to the aforementioned rules, I was undoubtedly foolish to think we could continue our “justfriendship” without any speed bumps.
About a day or two before he was about to go under the knife for knee surgery, he was complaining about his six-month celibacy and how it needed to end before he lost all mobility in his knee. My advice was to go get some, do yo thang, boy! Trust me, I am all about getting some – sex is natural, listen to Hugh Hefner and just appreciate and stare – even better if another party or three is involved. But, next thing I know, Fish is asking me if I want to be the lucky party! HOLD UP, WAIT A MINUTE, TIME OUT, PAUSE. “It was worth a shot,” he said. Then all of a sudden, he gets upset with me when I don’t immediately text him back, gets peeved when I don’t call him when HE told me to, and wants to chill in and watch movies and drink wine together at night? Excuse me, when did our FRIENDship turn into a RELATIONship? No jumping ships here, sailor. Stay on your own boat.
After this fiasco and I (again) CLEARLY communicated we were “just friends,” things went back to “normal.” Except now, I know what’s in his mind and I feel like I’m faking a friendship with him. I know as soon as he finds a girl to occupy his mind, it will most likely go away, but I am as of now unsure how to act. One of my fortes is definitely call-outs and making awkward situations even more awkward so as to really just do the reverse, but I can also act completely normal once a situation has been made awkward. Did that even make sense? Nonetheless, awkward situations are my specialty. But it feels as if the friendship is now ruined, tainted, a fallacy. The tension is just a little more tangible.
What must one do to maintain a strict friendship with the opposite sex? This is extremely narcissistic and terrible to say but I’ll say it anyway – I can literally think of only ONE male friend of mine who I know would never, never hook up with me if the right timing and opportunity appeared. The exception to the exception. Is this true for everyone? How do I throw the rules out the window? I enjoy the camaraderie and easygoing qualities of male friendship, but how do I keep it that way? If anyone has the answer – tell me now. Maybe I will implant a third eyeball or something. Or maybe I should just accept it - just ask Ryan Reynolds in Just Friends or Patrick Dempsey in Made of Honor. The worst.
